More Legal Help, Not Fewer Lawyers: Why Legal Action Supports Petition 26-04
Written by: Legal Action of Wisconsin
Wisconsin’s justice gap is growing. A proposal before the Wisconsin Supreme Court offers a practical way to help narrow it.
Imagine facing eviction without an attorney. Or trying to defend yourself against a debt collection lawsuit when you don’t understand the court process. Or living in a rural Wisconsin community where finding an attorney to take your case can be nearly impossible.
For thousands of Wisconsinites, these aren’t hypothetical situations. They are the reality of navigating our civil legal system.
The problem isn’t that these individuals don’t need a lawyer. It’s that too often, they cannot get one.
That’s why Legal Action of Wisconsin supports Petition 26-04, a proposal before the Wisconsin Supreme Court that would allow qualified, trained legal advocates to provide limited legal assistance under the supervision of licensed Wisconsin attorneys.
We believe this proposal could transform how legal aid organizations serve their clients, particularly in rural communities and high-volume courts where people routinely face significant legal consequences without representation.
Wisconsin has an access-to-justice problem
The numbers tell a troubling story.
According to the Legal Services Corporation’s 2022 Justice Gap Study, low-income Americans received no legal help or insufficient legal help for 92% of the civil legal problems that substantially impacted their lives.
Cost is a significant barrier. Among those who did not seek legal help for at least one problem, 46% cited concerns about cost.
Wisconsin faces additional challenges.
A November 2025 report from the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s Attorney Recruitment and Retention Committee documented serious geographic disparities in the availability of attorneys:
- 73% of Wisconsin’s attorneys are concentrated in judicial districts containing just 45% of the state’s population.
- Northern Wisconsin lost nearly 8% of its active attorneys and the southwest region of the state saw a decline of over 13% between 2020 and 2025.
- The number of attorneys associated with Wisconsin circuit court cases declined nearly 10% between 2017 and 2024.
These statistics illustrate a difficult reality: access to legal help depends heavily on where someone lives and whether they can afford to pay.
For Legal Action and other civil legal aid providers, that reality is familiar. Our attorneys work hard to help as many people as possible, supported by dedicated volunteer lawyers. But the volume of unmet need far exceeds the resources available.
We cannot solve this problem simply by asking already overextended attorneys to take on more cases.
A practical way to extend the reach of legal aid
Petition 26-04 would create a new category of certified legal professionals who could provide limited legal services under attorney supervision.
These legal advocates could, within their approved practice areas, advise clients, negotiate on their behalf, prepare legal documents, and appear in certain court and administrative proceedings.
Consider what that could mean in practice.
A legal advocate working with a legal aid attorney might help a tenant navigate an eviction proceeding, negotiate a resolution, or represent a client at an authorized hearing. Another might assist someone defending a small claims debt collection case or seeking relief in a qualifying family law matter.
These cases may involve what might seem to some as relatively small amounts of money, but their consequences can be enormous. Losing a home, having wages garnished, or losing access to one’s children can change the course of a person’s life.
For organizations like Legal Action, supervised advocates could help attorneys serve more clients while allowing lawyers to concentrate their time on complex litigation, legal strategy, and matters requiring their particular expertise.
It would not eliminate the need for attorneys. It would make their work go further.
Importantly, the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s own Attorney Recruitment and Retention Committee recommended exploring a limited license practitioner program for certain civil and family matters as one response to the state’s attorney shortage. That recommendation was exploratory rather than an endorsement of this particular petition, but it demonstrates that the need for new service models has been recognized within the judiciary itself.
What about the impact on private practice?
Questions about how this proposal could affect practicing attorneys and law firms deserve serious consideration. But it’s important to understand the problem the petition is designed to solve.
Much of the need this proposal addresses exists outside the traditional market for paid legal representation.
These are folks who are facing evictions and cannot afford even a modest legal fee, or a person disputing a relatively small debt for whom hiring an attorney would cost more than the amount at issue.
These are not necessarily clients choosing between a private attorney and a legal advocate. Often, they are people choosing between finding free legal assistance and facing the legal system entirely alone.
The proposed rule is also carefully limited. It does not authorize legal advocates to establish independent practices or provide unrestricted legal representation. Advocates must work under a licensed Wisconsin attorney through a qualifying firm or organization. The proposal excludes criminal matters, appellate proceedings, many higher-value civil claims, and other specified matters.
The rule would be available to qualifying private firms as well as legal aid organizations, and it would be reasonable to evaluate its effects as implemented. But we believe its greatest potential lies in expanding representation where traditional legal services are already scarce or financially out of reach.
The goal isn’t to divide existing legal work among more providers. It’s to make legal help available to people who currently receive none.
Better access benefits the entire legal system
When people enter court without legal assistance, the consequences extend beyond the individuals involved.
Self-represented litigants may struggle to understand deadlines, identify relevant legal issues, prepare appropriate documents, or navigate hearings. Judges and court personnel must manage proceedings involving individuals unfamiliar with the rules and procedures.
Qualified, supervised legal advocates could help address these challenges.
More people receiving meaningful legal assistance could mean better-prepared filings, more informed negotiations, fewer avoidable procedural problems, and more efficient court proceedings.
And for the individuals involved, receiving legal assistance can make a profound difference in their ability to participate meaningfully in the process and understand their rights and options.
A legal system that works more effectively for the people who use it benefits judges, attorneys, court staff, and the public. It also has the potential to strengthen public confidence that the legal system is fair and accessible.
These outcomes will depend on thoughtful implementation, training, and oversight. But they are important potential benefits that deserve consideration alongside questions about how the proposal might affect legal practice.
Attorney supervision and accountability remain essential
Expanding access to legal help should never mean compromising the quality of that help.
The proposed rule establishes requirements intended to protect clients and preserve professional accountability.
Among other safeguards, legal advocates would be subject to eligibility and background-check requirements, substantive and ethics training, written attorney supervision agreements, and client informed-consent requirements.
Supervising attorneys and their organizations would retain professional responsibilities, including oversight, conflicts checks, and responsibility for client funds. A standing committee would maintain a public certification roster and have authority to investigate complaints and suspend or revoke certification.
The rule also limits the types of proceedings and matters in which advocates may participate.
These protections and ensuring that legal advocates receive meaningful training and supervision appropriate to the work they perform are important. Legal Action views those responsibilities as central to making this model successful.
We need more ways to deliver justice
Attorneys will always be essential to a functioning justice system. We need more of them, particularly in underserved communities. We also need stronger funding for civil legal aid, continued investment in pro bono representation, and strategies to recruit and retain lawyers throughout Wisconsin.
But we cannot afford to wait for those efforts alone to close the justice gap.
Research on rural legal access has emphasized the importance of developing coordinated systems of assistance that match people’s needs with the right level of professional support. Not every legal problem requires the same intervention, and a person seeking help should be able to find a meaningful path forward.
Supervised legal advocates offer one promising way to build that capacity. For Legal Action, the question is ultimately a straightforward one:
When we know that people are facing life-changing legal problems without representation, shouldn’t we use every responsible tool available to help them?
We believe Petition 26-04 is an important step toward doing exactly that.
Add your voice
The State Bar of Wisconsin is gathering member input before its Board of Governors considers whether to support Petition 26-04.
We encourage Wisconsin attorneys to share their support by November 20, 2026.
Submit your feedback to the State Bar of Wisconsin
Your professional experience matters. A brief statement of support, especially one reflecting the unmet legal needs you have witnessed firsthand, can help inform this important discussion.